Directed by Luigi Falorni, Byambasuren Davaa. (STC) 87 min. Opens Aug 20.
If Walt Disney were alive, he'd probably be sick with envy that he
didn't hear the story of the weeping camel first. This enchanting
documentary about a baby camel and the mother who rejects him after a
difficult birth tugs at the heart strings as firmly as Bambi
did, but then loosens them for a sweetly gratifying reunion that Bambi
won't have with his mother until he's mounted beside her over the
fireplace.
To be fair, few have heard of weeping camels outside Mongolia,
where nomadic tribes tend to camels using ancient rituals just as
they're outfitting their tents with satellite TV. The clash of old- and
new-world cultures depicted in The Story of the Weeping Camel also,
in a way, brought the film into being. Co-director Byambasuren Davaa
came from Mongolia to attend film school in Munich, where she
befriended Italian student Luigi Falorni and told him about a ritual
she'd seen in a documentary as a child. Falorni was instantly hooked.
"She
told me this strange story about a mother camel rejecting her child and
the nomads playing and singing to her until she cries and accepts it
again," he says in an interview at the Miami International Film
Festival in January, where the film won Best Documentary. "I was
searching for a subject for my graduation film, and it occurred to me
right away that this story [has] a universal reach that goes far beyond
camel tears or the exotic, nomadic life."
Falorni and Davaa
travelled to the Gobi Desert in early 2002 looking for a family of
shepherds to feature in their film, which Falorni describes as a
"narrative documentary" since they planned the story in advance rather
than letting it emerge during shooting. After finding a
multi-generational family with a large herd of pregnant camels
(maximizing the odds that one would reject her calf), the filmmakers
returned with their tiny crew during the birthing season. "It could as
well have gone wrong -- or rather gone right -- with every camel,"
Falorni says of their risky venture. "If we hadn't gotten the story we
wanted, we probably would've gone home without a film and told our
financiers, 'Sorry, we made a hole in water,' as we say in Italy."
Fortunately
for them, but unfortunately for a rare white calf the herders named
Botok, the last delivery was painful, and the mother rejected Botok.
"After a few days, I thought, 'This is not good. She really doesn't
want him.' I felt responsible because I'd wanted it so bad," Falorni
says.
As they waited for the shepherds to fetch a musician from
town for the ritual, he and Davaa captured delightful (if dawdling)
scenes of family life. The kids are curious but also easily bored, such
as when they shush their great-grandfather because he's telling a story
they've heard before.
These scenes weren't scripted, but they
didn't always happen spontaneously. Falorni says that because he was
shooting on film instead of digital video, he often had to ask the
family to wait for him. The animals weren't as accommodating. "You
cannot direct a camel," Falorni says.
Botok is a pretty natural
talent, though. His cries are so gut-wrenching that you wonder whether
the filmmakers prolonged his estrangement for maximum emotional effect.
Falorni says the shepherds were the slowpokes, not him. "We knew that
they were going to do the ritual 'cause we talked to them about it
during research. But a rather long time elapsed before they actually
did. And the whole time they were feeding the calf with milk taken from
his mother, going back and forth, and the little one was weeping
because he didn't want just milk, he also wanted some contact with his
mother. I was like, 'Come on, go get the musician!'"
When the
ritual finally occurs, it's filled with suspense -- not over whether
it'll work (it's a family film, after all) but over why it works.
Falorni himself is still in the dark.
"Maybe why I never
questioned it is, it seems so natural. When you spend time with [the
nomads], singing and playing music is such a normal part of their
life." He speculates that the ritual uses sounds organic to the
environment to help the mother trust the herders.
Falorni's trust in magic over science has paid off handsomely.
He's now finished film school and promoting the doc at various
festivals. And what did his teachers think of his graduation project?
"I got an A," he laughs.
FROM THE CAMEL'S MOUTH
Magic schmagic. Falorni might not be curious why the ritual works,
but I was, so I hunted for camel experts online and emailed Ahmed
Tibary, Associate Professor of Theriogenology at Washington State
University after finding articles he'd written about the neonatal care
of camels.
I was surprised when Tibary replied that he'd never
heard of the ritual. He described factors that cause a dam (mother
camel) to reject her calf, which ironically include too much
manipulation of the herd by humans. He also explained that a camel's
long eyelashes, well-developed third eyelid and active lacrimal glands
are just there to help the animal survive sandstorms.
Then
Tibary added, "Although these secretions are tears and as such they
fulfill a specific physiological function, I do not believe this should
be calling weeping. The idea that camels 'weep' if mistreated is very
common in Arabia and North Africa. It is nice to humanize animal
behaviour because it does [encourage] a sense a responsibility on how
we treat animals but again I do not believe that this is sentimental
weeping."
Looks like the ritual's secret is still safe with Botok and his mother.