On Screen

Buddha Collapsed Out of Shame

  • Favourite  
  • Recommend:

BY Adam Nayman   February 27, 2008 14:02

Editorial Rating:
Starring Nikbakht Noruz, Abdolali Hoseinali. Written and directed by Hana Makhmalbaf. (PG) 81 min. Screens Feb 28, 8pm at the Isabel Bader Theatre as part of the Human Rights Watch International Film Festival.

At age 19, Hana Makhmalbaf has two feature films to her credit; the first, Joy of Madness (2004), was a behind-the-scenes doc detailing the production of her similarly prodigious sister Samira’s film At Five in the Afternoon.  With Buddha Collapsed Out of Shame (Feb. 28, 8pm, Isabel Bader) Makhmalbaf the (even) younger moves out of her family’s long shadow. It’s a deceptively muted — and then climactically explosive — broadside against the Taliban set in the Afghani city of Bamian.

It’s the same place where, in 2001, the Taliban destroyed a pair of massive fifth-century Buddha carvings — an international scandal already documented in Christian Frei’s 2005 film The Giant Buddhas. The magnificent statues loom in absentia over Makhmalbaf’s pointed parable. Inspired by her neighbour’s recitations, smiley post-toddler Baktay (Nikbakht Noruz) decides she wants to go to school.  Her first unofficial lesson is in economics, as she tries to barter some eggs for the pen and paper she’ll need for class. That’s a head-scratcher, but nothing compared to the ensuing tutorial in culture studies, as she’s menaced by a callow cabal of boys playing “Taliban.”

The equation of some junior bullies with a brutal, stifling theocracy may read as didactic, or play that way, as it did in The Kite Runner. But the film’s naturalistic feel and brief running time ameliorate the bluntness of the allegory. The last shot, meanwhile, ensures that it retains its sting.

Email us at: LETTERS@EYEWEEKLY.COM or send your questions to EYEWEEKLY.COM
625 Church St, 6th Floor, Toronto M4Y 2G1
Film Finder
|
GO

Related Stories

J’ai tué ma mere (I Killed My Mother)
Those arriving late to the story of Montreal upstart Xavier Dolan may wonder what the fuss has been about. After all, Dolan’s feature debut — made before the child-actor-turned-auteur turned 20 — has attracted much hype since it became a Cannes sensation.

Saint John of Las Vegas
A great cast is hung out to dry in this low-energy quirk-comedy that seems to exist solely for its desert climes and unrealized premise.

Frozen
For a film that can be summed up pretty much in five words — snowboarders get stuck on chairlift — Frozen is remarkable for wringing a maximum amount of tension and terror out of its minimalist concept.

MORE INSIDE