On Screen

S&M: Short and Male

  • Favourite  
  • Recommend:

BY Adam Nayman   May 14, 2008 15:05

Editorial Rating:
S & M: SHORT AND MALE
Directed by Howard Goldberg. (STC)  86 min. Opens May 16.

Dully conventional technique exacerbates the shortcomings of this would-be crowd-pleaser about heightism, which premiered in Toronto last month at Hot Docs and now scores a theatrical release. Montreal-based filmmaker Howard Goldberg’s concerns about the indignities suffered by diminutive males are not entirely without merit, but he hasn’t shaped the material carefully enough. The film feels like a series of tangents spackled together by a cloying musical score rather than a well-argued social critique.

Goldberg spends far too much time on the predictable personal gripes of the North American interviewees, including a stand-up comic so tersely unfunny that he suggests a Mr. Show character. Most of the avenues of inquiry yield dead ends (i.e., personal anecdotes that prove meaningful only to the tellers), but an investigation into height-based hiring practices in China (imagine Randy Newman lyrics written into law) and the growing demand for limb-lengthening surgery exerts some real pull. Perhaps this is because it’s the only section of the film unencumbered by cutesiness — by the time Goldberg is reduced to a glossy shopping montage, it’s clear that he might have been better off making S & M as a short subject.

Email us at: LETTERS@EYEWEEKLY.COM or send your questions to EYEWEEKLY.COM
625 Church St, 6th Floor, Toronto M4Y 2G1
Film Finder
|
GO

Related Stories

J’ai tué ma mere (I Killed My Mother)
Those arriving late to the story of Montreal upstart Xavier Dolan may wonder what the fuss has been about. After all, Dolan’s feature debut — made before the child-actor-turned-auteur turned 20 — has attracted much hype since it became a Cannes sensation.

Frozen
For a film that can be summed up pretty much in five words — snowboarders get stuck on chairlift — Frozen is remarkable for wringing a maximum amount of tension and terror out of its minimalist concept.

Dear John
Novelist Nicholas Sparks earns another cheque with Dear John, a weepie that packs the many sources of heartbreak found in his previous work (The Notebook, A Walk To Remember) into 106 minutes: cancer, war, 9/11, autism and long-distance romance all befall

MORE INSIDE