On Disc

God Help the Girl

MATADOR

  • Favourite  
  • Recommend:

BY Stuart Berman   June 30, 2009 21:06

Editorial Rating:

Since their emergence 13 years ago, Belle and Sebastian have been held up as a totem of indie insularity, the kind of band fans want to smother with their cardigan-clad arms and protect from the vagaries of the modern world. But if it were up to the band’s chief lyricist Stuart Murdoch, he’d give up all the fanzine plaudits in the world for a chance to play song doctor to the stars. For his first solo project, God Help the Girl — the soundtrack to an as-yet-uncompleted film — he essentially hosts his own version of Pop Idol, farming out songs to a cast of mostly unknown, mostly female singers recruited from other bands and classified ads, and slathering them in gaudy, talk-show orchestra arrangements. Alas, the open-audition gambit works better in concept than in practice — budding diva Britney Stallings’ Philly-soul makeover of Belle and Sebastian’s “Funny Little Frog” oversells the song’s desperation — but in Catherine Ireton (who figures on 10 of the 14 songs here), Murdoch may have finally discovered the reliable female foil he’s been looking for since Isobel Campbell ditched B&S back in ’02. 

Email us at: LETTERS@EYEWEEKLY.COM or send your questions to EYEWEEKLY.COM
625 Church St, 6th Floor, Toronto M4Y 2G1
Film Finder
|
GO

Related Stories

Archie Bronson Outfit: Coconut
Driven underground, maybe, by the modicum of buzz that greeted them in the mid-’00s, Archie Bronson Outfit can now be commended for apparently taking a powder for a few years while their third album, Coconut, gestated. With the ink on their Domino deal lon

Broken Bells
Danger Mouse strikes again with another oddball side project, this time collaborating with The Shins’ frontman James Mercer as new duo Broken Bells. Similarly to SoCal-inclined temperament displayed on his band’s 2007 disc, Wincing The Night Away, Mercer’s

Liars: Sisterworld
Liars fifth album, Sisterworld, is both surprisingly straightforward and nearly impenetrable, and the fact that it seems at odds with itself is one of the many things the disc has going for it. Liars’ experimental side has a tendency to creep along in the

MORE INSIDE